Skip to content
Family Law

Sham Marriage in Colombia: What the Supreme Court Ruled

Can a civil marriage in Colombia be declared fake? The Supreme Court (SC2016-2025) says yes, but only with serious evidence. Case analysis.

Nancy Astrid Arango Founding Partner
Reviewed by Nancy Astrid Arango, lawyer Updated on 6 min read

Case file

Court
Supreme Court of Justice of Colombia — Civil, Agrarian and Rural Cassation Chamber
Ruling
SC2016-2025
Date
Decision
Appeal dismissed — the marriage was not declared a sham

Read the ruling (official PDF, Spanish)

Key takeaway: Colombia’s Supreme Court of Justice (ruling SC2016-2025, November 6, 2025) confirmed that a civil marriage can be declared a sham because it is a contract, and that such cases can reach the Supreme Court on cassation. But it set a high bar: the spouses saying it was fake is not enough; serious, decisive evidence is required. In this case, which began in the courts of Armenia, the claim failed.

A 2004 marriage someone tried to “erase” 12 years after the divorce

The facts, as summarized by the Court in its own explainer video (using fictitious names):

Year Event
1989 Leonardo and Mercedes have a son
2004 They marry in a civil ceremony before a notary in Tuluá
2010 They divorce and divide their marital property by public deed
2021 Leonardo asks the court to declare the marriage a sham, which would make the divorce non-existent
2022 Pedro, the son of a deceased woman Leonardo claims he lived with for 36 years, joins the case
2024 The Family Court of Armenia rules for Leonardo
2025 The Superior Court of Armenia reverses that ruling
2025 The Supreme Court dismisses the appeal: the marriage stands

Leonardo claimed the marriage was only meant to help him enter the United Kingdom, where Mercedes lived. The visa was denied anyway. His real interest surfaced later: in a separate case, he was seeking recognition of a common-law union (unión marital de hecho) with the deceased woman. Erasing the marriage would have restored his single status, to Pedro’s detriment.

What the Court decided

  1. A civil marriage is a formal contract (arts. 113 and 115 of the Colombian Civil Code), so the doctrine of simulation applies (art. 1766): the parties’ real intent prevails over the written form (art. 1618).
  2. These cases can reach cassation, because the retroactive effects of an absolute simulation are equivalent to those of a challenge to civil status.
  3. A sham marriage is not an annulment. Annulment takes effect when declared (art. 149 of the Civil Code); an absolute simulation wipes out the marriage from the beginning.
  4. The spouses’ word is not enough. Legal acts are presumed serious and genuine (CSJ SC1008-2024 and SC503-2023). Circumstantial evidence is the most common route (CSJ SC3979-2022), and it must be serious and decisive. A party’s self-serving statement is not a confession (art. 191 of the General Code of Procedure), and the ex-spouse’s agreement does not count either when a third party bears the harm.

The evidence that defeated the claim

  • The couple already had a son in 1989, fifteen years before the wedding.
  • They married in 2004 and divorced in 2010, dividing their property: two consistent acts of will.
  • The plaintiff admitted he wanted the sham declaration because of the common-law union case.
  • The dates did not add up: he said he had lived with another partner since 1984.
  • He waited more than ten years after the divorce.
  • He concealed the common-law union case in his complaint, which the Court weighed against him (art. 241 of the General Code of Procedure).

What this means for you

  • Foreigners married in Colombia who consider claiming their marriage was “just for papers” will need consistent, external evidence, not just their own testimony.
  • Heirs and partners affected by a sham marriage claim can join the case and oppose it.
  • Consistency and timing matter: marrying, divorcing and dividing property are acts a judge will treat as proof that the marriage was real.

This article is for information only and is not legal advice. Learn about our family law practice or contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Can a civil marriage in Colombia be declared a sham?

Yes. The Supreme Court held that a civil marriage, being a contract, can be declared simulated, but only with serious and decisive circumstantial evidence. The spouses’ word alone is not enough.

Is it enough if both spouses admit they married only for a visa?

No. A party’s statement in its own favor is not a confession (art. 191 of the General Code of Procedure), and the other spouse’s agreement does not count either when the harm falls on a third party.

What is the difference between a sham marriage and an annulment?

Annulment takes effect from the moment it is declared (art. 149 of the Civil Code). An absolute simulation erases the marriage from the start, as if it had never existed.

Can a third party oppose the claim?

Yes. A third party with a direct interest can join the case and defend their rights, as the son of the plaintiff’s late partner did here.

Sources

  • Supreme Court of Justice of Colombia, Civil, Agrarian and Rural Cassation Chamber. Ruling SC2016-2025, November 6, 2025, reporting justice Octavio Augusto Tejeiro Duque. Read the ruling (official PDF, in Spanish)
  • Supreme Court of Justice. Video “Simulación de matrimonios civiles” (January 24, 2026, in Spanish). Watch on YouTube
  • Provisions cited: Colombian Civil Code, arts. 113, 115, 149, 1618 and 1766; General Code of Procedure, arts. 191, 241 and 334.

This article is general information for informational purposes only and is not legal advice for any specific case. To review your situation, consult a lawyer.

Updated on November 18, 2026

Tags

sham marriagemarriage for a visaColombian family lawcommon-law unionColombian Supreme Court
About the author

Nancy Astrid Arango

Founding Partner

Family law specialist from Universidad La Gran Colombia. She advises, represents and supports individuals and families in family, civil and administrative law, in administrative and judicial proceedings, with technical rigor and a deep human approach.